Ancient history
Mar. 3rd, 2009 05:23 pmShetterly and Patrick Nielsen Hayden discuss Katrina and racism.
This was totally fascinating. pnh did quite a lot of hard smacking down and explaining and stuff.
There were many headdesk moments but the one that made me laugh out loud was Shetterly googling "katrina racism" to find out if the world thought racism was important or not!
This was totally fascinating. pnh did quite a lot of hard smacking down and explaining and stuff.
I'm most struck by your evident notions that we should "stop talking about race" because (1) class is really, really important, (2) George W. Bush has appointed some black people to high office, and (3) some rich black people are shits. The first is indubitably true, the second is true but not particularly interesting, and the third, while true, is the argument of a five-year-old. Good grief. Some Native Americans kept black slaves, too; I suppose this means we should stop talking about the extermination of the continent's pre-Columbian population when we discuss American history. Indeed, since people everywhere tend to oppress those weaker than them, we should just stop discussing power and oppression altogether.That's a really good response.
There were many headdesk moments but the one that made me laugh out loud was Shetterly googling "katrina racism" to find out if the world thought racism was important or not!